Evaluate seems at progress serving to farmers and crofters cope with sea eagle impression
Issued on behalf of the Sea Eagle National Stakeholder Panel. A review of the White-tailed Eagle Action Plan by key stakeholders has looked at the progress made and developed new recommendations to help farmers and crofters deal with the impact of sea eagles on their livestock.
These recommendations will be included in an extension to the plan over the next three years. The report is available on the NatureScot website.
From 2017, the Sea Eagle Management Scheme has engaged with 164 holdings, covering 156,489 hectares and 71,516 breeding ewes. The scheme budget, funded by NatureScot, has increased from £72,000 in 2015 to £225,000 in 2020.
Stakeholders have worked closely with individual farmers and crofters on ‘monitor farms’ to test different management techniques and develop a toolbox of measures, aimed at reducing the impacts sea eagles can have on hill sheep flocks. These included diversionary feeding, scaring devices and licenced manipulation of nest sites outside of the breeding season. The work had mixed results in terms of reducing impacts.
White-tailed Eagle, copyright David MacLeman, from the surfbirds galleries
To better understand the scale of sea eagle interactions with sheep, observers spent a significant amount of time on the hill; however, there were few observations of direct interactions, as it is possible that the presence of observers, on open hillsides, deters sea eagle activity. But NatureScot has collected a significant body of circumstantial evidence through work with individual farmers and crofters which points to significant impacts in some areas.
New ideas on improving habitat to support natural prey species will be explored. The scheme may also include licenced activities to reduce serious agricultural damage in situations where all other options have been unsuccessful.
Rae McKenzie, NatureScot’s Policy & Operations Manager, said:
“We recognise the serious concerns that some farmers and crofters have about the impact of sea eagles on their livestock, and we’re committed to continuing working closely with them to find solutions. The scheme is about finding a balance between livestock farming and wildlife and recognising the benefits that each brings to us all. This is a great example of working together, with National Farmers Union Scotland, Scottish Crofting Federation, RSPB Scotland, Forest Enterprise Scotland and others, to tackle issues faced by farmers and crofters, while also ensuring healthy populations of this spectacular species.”
Yvonne White of the Scottish Crofting Federation said: “Sea Eagle predation can have a significant financial and emotional impact on crofters. Notwithstanding, the Scottish Crofting Federation remains committed to working with NatureScot to find ways of mitigating these negative impacts.”
Chair of NFU Scotland’s Environment and Land Use Committee, Angus MacFadyen said: “The Action Plan has made progress in its first three years but a significant number of farmers and crofters continue to see the presence of White-tailed Eagles (WTEs) have an impact on their sheep flocks. We welcome the significant increase in funding since 2015 and collaborative work on the ground through the monitor farm trials to try and reduce the impact of WTEs on livestock but, with 164 holdings now engaging with the scheme, it reflects the recorded increase in the spread and numbers of these birds. Our recent member survey revealed that, unfortunately the majority of respondents did not feel the current action plan had made a significant impact on reducing WTE predation. With the next three years of the Action plan currently being revised, NFU Scotland will be working with the partnership to ensure that Action Plan delivers on significantly reducing the losses that some farmers and crofters are suffering.”
Read the full document White-tailed Eagle Action Plan Review 2020.